Cedar Creek Plantation
Forestlands and Hunting Preserve

The Butler County Buck

DISCLAIMER:  Cedar Creek Plantation does not claim to have today, have had in the past, or to have in the future a deer of this caliber.  The hunter claims this buck was taken in the surrounding area, however, most of our mature bucks will never grow to this size.  Do not expect to harvest a buck this size on your hunt at Cedar Creek Plantation.




 

The Hunter's Story
In early January, pictures of this buck started circulating around local hunting clubs and eventually on the internet, with the similar story that a local deer processor and taxidermist had claimed to killed the deer in northwest Butler County.  The hunter claimed that the deer was legally harvested on private property.  When the pictures first surfaced, the rumors surrounding them ranged from expected to outrageous.  Many believed that the photos had been digitally edited and that the rack does not exist at all.  There was also large speculation that the deer may have been taken at night or illegally in some way.  Others claimed it was shot in Canada and flown back to Alabama.  The claimed unofficial B&C score for the deer is 205" gross and 200" net, scored as a typical 12 point rack.  If verified, the buck would have been the number one all-time typical buck from the state of Alabama.

The Rest of the Story
Enter Van Dykes Taxidermy.  Van Dykes sells reproduction racks for whitetail deer.  It turns out that they have one for sell that has strikingly similar characteristic to the one that the processor had claimed to kill.  Gary Beigh, the creator of the reproduction rack should be proud.  His rack is so realistic that someone could buy the rack, mount it on another deer's head, take lots of pictures of the deer and convince  many people that he had killed it.  What would be someone's motivation for claiming they had killed a buck that they hadn't?  Bragging rights to your buddies, publicity for yourself or business, or personal reasons we can't understand.  In today's world, we know that you can't believe everything you see.  But if you can't take a man for his word, there is not much left to believe.  Take a look at the reproduction rack for yourself.  The product can be found at  http://www.vandykestaxidermy.com/product/01000128/

 



 


 

 

 

 

 




Cedar Creek Plantation

173 Pletcher Street
Prattville, AL 36067
Phone: (334) 365-9521

cedarcreek@knology.net

 

 
 

Home Page

About

Deer Hunting

Turkey Hunting

Quail Hunting

Hog Hunting

Pricing